I sat alone at the table in Union Station, waiting for my
train and picking through my General Tso’s Chicken when the man approached
me. It was a familiar situation; nothing
new. We’ve all been there in one form or
another.
“Hey buddy,” he says.
“Me and my lady are just trying to get home. Just need 80 cents.”
80 cents? I think. What an
odd amount. But I brush him away
with a wave of my hand and a mumbled, “No, sorry.” It’s almost a reflex, a nervous twitch.
I’m surprised by how quickly he moves away, eyes to the next
table and me no more than another piece of furniture in the way.
80 cents.
That cynical part of my mind starts to run through some
calculations.
80 cents is a pretty specific amount—people are more likely
to respond to specificity, especially when it’s so low. Everyone’s got 80 cents, though probably not
in change, which means he’d get a dollar from anyone who responds. Maybe two.
And at the rate he was moving, he could hit a new group of people every
few seconds, and if even one out of ten gave a dollar…
I decided he’d get minimum wage in no time. Minimum wage and then some.
Which was troubling, in what it said about the minimum wage.
But even more troubling—and in a big way—was the handy
methodology I’d used to relegate the man to some mischievous character in a
story, some inferior category that I was justified in writing off.
After all, how could I know he really needed that 80 cents?
And who’s to say I didn’t need the money myself?
I certainly can’t speak for everyone when I say these are
the kinds of mental hoops I jump through whenever I see someone begging on the
street, homeless and with a cardboard sign wandering through traffic or waiting
in front of the subway. I’ll be honest—it
makes me uncomfortable.
And I think that’s a good thing.
After all, these men and women are human beings, certainly
no different than me. Perhaps they’d
fallen on some tough times, made some difficult decisions, had nowhere to
turn. How can I know? Whatever the case, whatever the story, it should make me uncomfortable—uncomfortable
in that there’s so little I can do to change anything, uncomfortable in that so
many people pass these men and women by with barely a glance, uncomfortable
that sometimes I’m one of them.
At the very least, I should try to make eye contact, to
affirm that piece of humanity that we share between us. At the very least, I should nod, offering
some greeting. But then I’d be forced to
look suffering in the face, injustice, difficulty, my own powerlessness—that darker
side of the human experience.
I’d be forced to admit that I had no answers, no magic
bullet solution, no logical way to say, “Oh, but this is the right way to proceed…”
Perhaps I’d be forced to admit that I’m not as courageous as
I’d like to think.
And so it’s easier to run through those mental hoops, to
comfort myself in the fact that giving a dollar here and there is not solving
any problems but in fact contributing to them.
That studies have been done, good people have shared their advice and
insight, that in fact giving handouts is not the way, is hardly even a band-aid
over a gaping wound. There are shelters
and food pantries and organizations...
And so the reasoning goes.
But I always come back to that one question: do they really need my money? Will it really
make a difference?
And perhaps that most cynical piece of all: are they telling
the truth?
When I was in Bolivia, a woman came to the volunteer house
looking for money. 300 bolivianos, she
said. For her daughter to go to the
hospital.
She wailed and cried and we brought her into the house,
debating what to do. After all, 300
bolivianos was less than $45 and split between three people… But we were living on a volunteer’s salary,
and we weren’t there to give handouts.
And how odd that she just happened to stumble upon the only house of
Americans on the block… We didn’t know
the woman.
She sat with us for the better part of an hour, switching
between wailing sobs and pleasantries.
We gave her juice and pastries until finally we learned that she was in
fact a known scammer. She often went
from house to house tricking money out of people as she’d nearly done with us.
We sent her on her way.
There is no magic bullet answer. But I remember thinking after that experience
that, although we had nearly been scammed out of a substantial sum of money (in
Bolivian terms), I couldn’t help wondering if that woman didn’t in fact need
the cash. Sure, we’d been lied to, taken
advantage of, but there’s something about the desperation that drives a person
to beg that shouldn’t be taken lightly.
When we’re forced to assume the role of something so
culturally taboo, so commonly looked down upon and scoffed at, aren’t we really
in need of something? Financially,
maybe. Emotionally, definitely. Some piece of human connection.
I’m not sure giving out money to every homeless person you
meet is the answer. I’m not sure giving
them your leftovers after a big meal is, either. I’m not sure smiling and offering a warm
greeting as you move along is right. In
fact, I’m not sure what the answer is, other than this: we’re all people in
need, and any action that acknowledges that is probably the right one. We’re all begging for something. And the conscious effort to do so in such a
dramatic way should not be viewed lightly.
In fact, it should bring about a degree of discomfort. Because I know it forces me to come face to
face with my own powerlessness and my own need.
No comments:
Post a Comment